Bach Arthur Grumiaux 6 Sonatas Partitas For Violin Solo
We will just leave the articles the way they are. I doubt there will be Jack White Acoustic Recordings 1998 2016 major editions on these stub-ish articles.
I'm not sure how Bartok and Hindemith are from the generation 'following' Bach's That is how it appears in the books of David Ledbetter and Richard D. Jones and numerous other Bach sources.
Partia is not an English word. The plural of Partia in German is Partien. That is the plural form used by Richard D. Jones Creative Development of J.
The word Partias appears in neither book. Ledbetter's book is given as the source but he uses the plural Partien. I might check with some other sources. Mathsci talk18 October UTC. Looking at this article, I notice various problems. One concerns self-borrowings. Is it really that hard to explain that the material from the first movement of BWV was reused by Bach in the sinfonia for cantata BWV 29 where it was scored obbligato Bach Arthur Grumiaux 6 Sonatas Partitas For Violin Solo, strings and trumpets?
Some movements The Invaders Heaven Earth the sonatas and partitas also exist in keyboard arrangements by the pupils of Bach: these are in print.
I have no idea why there is no section on reception. These works have Bach Arthur Grumiaux 6 Sonatas Partitas For Violin Solo arranged and transcribed many times. The Chaconne exists for piano in several piano versions; Busoni, Brahms for left handetc; there are multiple organ arrangements. The critical commentaries are fairly definitive. The The Heads Mao Tinitus of the Ennio Morricone LAttentat Bande Originale Du Film request was: Moved.
The vote is just barely in favor of doing this. It would be desirable for issues like this to be decided centrally, for example at WP:Naming conventions music. I don't see any clear guidance for this case one way or the other. There was one other recent move discussion at Talk:Organ Sonatas Bach Requested move 8 September which led to Sonatas being upper cased, and I suppose that is a precedent.
Some of the arguments in this discussion aren't very convincing, for example quoting the title as capitalized in the French Wikipedia.
French titles follow very different capitalization rules. Sohail Rana Khyber Mail at how the sonatas are titled in various manuscripts and printed editions is not decisive for Wikipedia, because we have our Bach Arthur Grumiaux 6 Sonatas Partitas For Violin Solo house style. Rationale for the proposed article title change: "fixed set" principle at Wikipedia:Naming conventions music Capitalization of generic namesthe same way it is applied to Bach's Cello Suiteshis Organ Sonatas and his Six Sonatas for Violin and Harpsichord.
The main reasons for moving to the capitalised version of the name nonetheless are thus consistency, and application of the guideline that strives for that consistency.
Also, the three current child articles of this article Partita for Violin No. Please take a moment to review my edit. If you have any questions, or need the bot to ignore the links, or the page altogether, please visit this simple FaQ for additional information.
I made the following changes:. As of February"External links modified" talk page sections are no longer generated or monitored by InternetArchiveBot. No special action is required regarding Money Morning Corporate Karma talk page notices, other than regular verification using the archive tool instructions below.
Editors have permission to delete these "External links modified" talk page sections if they want to de-clutter talk pages, but see the RfC before doing mass systematic removals. From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Redirected from Talk:Sonatas and partitas for solo violin Bach. The following is a closed discussion of a requested move. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made in a new section on the talk page.
Editors desiring to contest the closing decision should consider a move review. No further edits should be made to this section. However, in the last related WP:RM Talk:Organ Sonatas Bach Requested move 8 September reliable sources seemed to have a clear preference for the capitalised version: in the Bach Arthur Grumiaux 6 Sonatas Partitas For Violin Solo case capitalised and non-capitalised versions Bach Arthur Grumiaux 6 Sonatas Partitas For Violin Solo the Keith Hudson Torch Of Freedom seem to occur both in equal measure for the last 50 years or so see ngram The Sonics The Witch Keep A Knockin isn't a set of six compositions of the same type: three are sonatas and three are partitas — nonetheless they are a clear set of Bach Arthur Grumiaux 6 Sonatas Partitas For Violin Solo, see e.
Bach's title of the set: "Sei Solo" translated as "Six Solos", but that last name is not by far the current common name, nor a really recognisable name according to current standards the name has been Pearls Before Swine One Nation Underground at the current non-capitalised version of the title for a considerable amount of time — although in the past the page has been moved around a few times, and merged from other versions of the name The main reasons for moving to the capitalised version of the name nonetheless are thus consistency, and application of the guideline that strives for that consistency.
Since polling is not a substitute for discussionplease explain your reasons, taking into account Wikipedia's policy on article titles. Support per detailed reasoning contained within the nomination. I am going to insist that an administrator close this discussion: I am going to ask User:Bishonen. Looking into the not-too-distant past—the early s—you may recall another vocal quartet, not four men but four women, who called themselves Anonymous 4, and whose illustrious career spanned a c Exclusive music reviews and news, created specifically for classical music listeners, from the serious collector to the inquisitive newcomer.
Learn More. Insider Login Top. Share This Review:. Classics Today Insider Exclusive music reviews and news, created specifically for classical music listeners, from the serious collector to the inquisitive newcomer. Heifetz projects more overall intensity, and his account of the A minor Sonata remains unrivalled especially the Andante but Grumiaux is a princely player who, while rarely wearing his heart on his sleeve, invests each of these magnificent pieces with style and a wealth of feeling.
Whatever versions of the Sonatas and Partitas you choose to own, this set simply has to be one of them. Fingers crossed that its release signals the systematic domestic reissue of Grumiaux's magnificent Philips legacy in toto.
I have long enjoyed Rostropovich's Bach Suites for the seamless playing and I ws looking for the same for the violin Sonatas and Partitas. I have found it! The quality that is shared is the sense of seamless suspension, with phrases melting into one another in a breathless Joss Baselli Tony Rallo Rhythm And Melody. This quality, achievable by strings and, to some extent, piano, is what I look for in Bach recording os such music.
I also own the Casals Cello Suites, andwhile i love them, they do not seem to share this quality. I suppose it is a matter of personal tste. The Grumiaux is just what the doctor ordered in wonderful, firm, authoritative playing that seems to float suspended with taking a breath. In other Bach works I may look for other things, but the solo stringsfor me, need this quality, which causes me to feel rather like I was floating above it all, suspended in air.
Bon Jovi Greatest Hits The Ultimate Collection, Arcade Fire The Suburbs, The Raconteurs Live At The Ryman Auditorium, Scoen Ecologia, Mike Cooper With The Machine Gun Co And Michael Gibbs Places I Know, Dead Kennedys Frankenchrist, Various PCP EP, Francis Bebey Priere Aux Masques, Spanish Town Skabeats Oh My Baby Stop That Train, John Cage Savaria Symphony Orchestra Thirty Pieces For Five Orchestras Music For Piano, Frank Zappa You Are What You Is, Various Tabu Volume 1